Rust-Oleum Reviews

Rust-Oleum has an overall rating of 3.4 based on 76 reviews. Customer feedback on Rust-Oleum is mixed: Rust-Oleum reviewers highlight positive aspects like easy to apply, good coverage, durable finish, wide color selection, which strongly appeal to DIY enthusiasts, homeowners, professional painters. However, Rust-Oleum is often criticized for its long drying time, inconsistent results, difficult cleanup, strong odor.

3.4/5.0

76 reviews

5 Stars

7

4 Stars

6

3 Stars

10

2 Stars

6

1 Star

1

All Rust-Oleum Reviews (76)
hello_ross048
May 23, 2026
"Worked Great on My Old Patio Table"
I used Rust-Oleum to fix up an old patio table, i’m really happy with how it turned out. The site made it easy to figure out which product I needed, and the color match was exactly what I was looking for. It went on smoothly and dried faster than I expected. I know some people can be picky about paint, but I really don’t have anything bad to say here. The table looks so much better now, so yeah, 5 stars from me.
CONKLIN
May 19, 2026
"Started Peeling Way Too Soon"
After just one winter, it already started peeling. I feel like I’ve had to explain this more than once, but that’s really all there is to it, it didn’t hold up. Definitely not buying it again.
Natalie-stone
May 04, 2026
"I used Rust-Oleum on a small metal shelf..."
I used Rust-Oleum on a small metal shelf, and it looked really good at first. The color came out how I wanted, and it dried smooth without much hassle.

After a couple weeks, though, I started seeing chips along the edges where things get bumped. I asked support about it, and they basically said it works best when the surface is prepped really well and the piece isn’t getting constant knocks. Fair enough, but I still thought it would be a bit tougher. I’d use it again for light-duty stuff, just not for anything that gets handled a lot.
hello_kelli423
May 02, 2026
"Good finish if you prep it right"
I use this on an old metal shelf and it came out nice in the end. The part where I rushed the sanding and cleaning didn’t stick too good, so I had to learn that the hard way. Once I actually prepped it proper, it was looking way better. I’d give it 4 stars, just make sure you don’t skip the prep steps.
Kristen-shields
April 25, 2026
"I used Rustoleum on a small…"
I used Rustoleum on a small table, and it looked good right after I finished it. The color went on smoothly and it dried faster than I expected. But after a couple of weeks, I started seeing scratches from keys and just normal everyday use. Nothing completely awful, but I really thought it would be a little tougher. Also, having to go through repeated verification just to leave a review was annoying. Overall, I’d say it’s fine for something decorative or stuff that won’t get touched much, but I wouldn’t use it on anything that gets regular use
hello_randall478
April 24, 2026
"Good Paint, But the Smell Lingers"
The paint went on smoothly, so no complaints there, but wooow the odor was stronger than I expected. I had the windows open and could still smell it for quite a while after. It wasn’t awful or anything, just not something I’d be excited to use indoors again...
JacquelineBuckner_01
April 20, 2026
"I was a little worried the cans might..."
I was a little worried the cans might not match exactly, but they all ended up being the same color. Everything blended really well, which definitely made me feel better about the project.
FredBurgess
April 15, 2026
"Fair outcome in the end"
I had an issue with some peeling paint, and the warranty team was a bit slow to get back to me. That said, they did end up replacing it, so I’d call it a “fair” experience overall.
betsyjenson5903
April 11, 2026
"Worked Better Than I Expected"
I picked up Rust-Oleum to freshen up an old patio chair set, and it covered a lot better than I thought it would. One can actually went far, so I didn't even have to run back and buy more. For the price, I really can’t complain at all
DAVIS
April 04, 2026
"Worked well on my old gate"
I used this on my old gate a few weeks back, and even after all that rain, the rust hasn’t really shown up again. The smell is definitely strong at first, so I wouldn’t use it too close to where you’re hanging around, but yeah, that stuff seems to have done what it was supposed to do
maryann_Vance96
March 30, 2026
"Stuck okay, but not perfectly"
I was in a relaxed mood when I put it on, and at first the adhesion seemed fine. After a bit, though, I noticed it started peeling in a few spots. Not terrible, but I wish it had stayed down better.
Robert-barreras
March 25, 2026
"Didn’t Feel Fair for an Outdoor Product"
I used this on my patio chairs and expected it to hold up better outside. After just a few rains, it started peeling and looking all patchy. I spent a good amount of time applying it, so it was frustrating to see it fail that quickly. If something is meant for outdoor use, I feel like it should be made to handle normal weather, otherwise it just doesn’t feel right to sell it that way.
hector.Stegman
March 15, 2026
"Color was about what I expected"
I used this spray paint on a small patio table, and the color was close to what it looked like online. I’d say it’s maybe a little darker in person, but not by much, and it still worked out fine. It went on smoothly and dried evenly. I’m taking off a star mostly because I think it would help if the website showed the color in a few different lighting situations...
joseph_Monson02
March 12, 2026
"I went in expecting to grab a…"
I went in expecting to grab a few things because the website said they were in stock, but the shelves were empty again. It’s such a simple thing, but somehow it turns into a hassle every time. Really frustrating to make the trip for nothing.
albert_Jahns85
March 11, 2026
"Good finish, but cleanup was a hassle"
I used a Rust-Oleum paint on a little shelf project, and the finish turned out nice. The annoying part was the cleanup. I thought it would rinse out easier, but the brushes took forever and my tray still had sticky spots after messing with it for a while. I also tried calling with a quick question and got transferred around, which was frustrating for something so simple. Not a total dealbreaker, but it was more work than I expected. I’d probably use it again, just with extra drop cloths and more patience next time
chrystalharrold3017
March 04, 2026
"Really well packed"
It was packed really well, so everything arrived safe and in good shape. I’m happy with it
samellabadman3723
February 23, 2026
"It looks decent overall, but it doesn’t…"
It looks decent overall, but it doesn’t feel as smooth as I was hoping. It’s okay, just not quite as polished as I expected.
clifford-Wingard
February 17, 2026
"A Little Messy to Apply"
It went on kind of messy for me. Not the smoothest application. Had to clean up around the edges a bit, but it was manageable.
John_arnold01
February 15, 2026
"Dented can and terrible timing"
I ordered from rustoleum and the can arrived dented, with paint leaked all inside the box. The paint itself seems like it’s probably fine, but the packaging was definitely not enough for something being shipped. Of course it showed up like this right when I needed to use it, so the timing made it even more frustrating. Cleaning up the mess was annoying, and I’d expect them to pack paint a lot better than that...
richardhughes3034
February 10, 2026
"I was expecting the refund to…"
I was expecting the refund to be a whole thing, especially since I had errands to run that day and didn’t feel like dealing with emails back and forth. But it came through really fast and there was no headache at all. Smooth experience.

View More Reviews

Rust-Oleum Q&A

Is Rustoleum.com a scam or a legit company?

AndrewTat
November 24, 2019

“Legit, of course. Or, why would I bother to review it?”

Can you share a success story using Rustoleum.com?

silverfrog592
November 24, 2019

“Every project that entails my using Rustoleum is a success.”

Have a question about Rust-Oleum?

Customer Reviews

Questions & Answers

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.